BLT Egg Salad

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

~ All the crowd-pleasing flavors of a BLT sandwich, in a healthy egg salad recipe! The perfect potluck salad for summer picnics … and the best-ever way to use up all those hard-boiled eggs each Easter! So versatile, too – it’s delicious as a sandwich or as a salad, nestled into leafy greens … even as a dip with whole grain crackers! ~

This Recipe Is:     Ready in 30 Minutes or Less    Make Ahead    Gluten Free (Depending on Optional Serving Choices)  

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

When it comes to holiday traditions, Easter is jam-crammed to overflowing.

Here in Ohio, though, we sometimes don’t get it all quite right.

We’re right on top of it when it comes to the religious traditions. We’ve got that down pat. But somewhere after church we’ve been known to run into … issues.

Take weather traditions, and the whole lovely idea of “spring” for example.

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

Easter (being a spring holiday and all) really should involve freshly cascading blooms, cut right from the garden, dewy and fragrant. It’s a brilliant idea, in concept. And yet, where I live, we often celebrate Easter with snowflakes blanketing all the daring, early crocuses and bending the pretty little necks of those first, hearty daffodils. *SIGH*

Oh, and let’s not forget fashion! There are definitely Easter fashion traditions! We’re talking pastel Easter bonnets and kid gloves, new white shoes and flouncy dresses!

But …

If you’re following along here, you probably realize the insanity of those traditions for Ohioans, too.

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}Right.

We buy darling Easter dresses, and then cram our little sweeties and their pretty dresses into snowsuits before church. (Snowsuits!) Or, if we’re really experiencing a heat wave one year, we might get away with just two or three cardigans and a ski cap. (It’s actually pretty similar to how we often handle princess costumes at Halloween. But that’s another story.)

This year we honestly did get a bit luckier on Easter, weather-wise. At my big family party, we actually hunted eggs outside … and all we needed was a warm bonfire and some sweatshirts. No daffodils or flouncy dresses for us (good thing, too – since smoky bonfire cinders and flounces don’t mix). But we still counted ourselves unusually lucky with such (ahem …) balmy weather.

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

Yeah, we just don’t always get those weather and fashion traditions quite right. But you know what we do get right?

Food! We’re great at food traditions!

And today, I wanted to share one of my absolute, personal faves … BLT Egg Salad!

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

If you have family members who are trying to eat gluten-free, remember that this egg salad recipe is just as delicious without the bread!

I’ve been making some version of this egg salad ever since I first saw the recipe for Egg Salad BLTs in Cooking Light magazine years ago. One of the highlights of my Easter every year is making BLT Egg Salad with all those leftover Easter eggs! It’s a tradition that never, ever fails … it always goes right!

And now it’s even more right! Healthier and portable, too!

I swapped nonfat Greek yogurt for Cooking Light’s original fat-free mayo and reduced-fat sour cream. And ya know what? No one will even notice!

Mmmmmm … I amped up some of the flavor components, too – this has egg salad has big BLT flavors!

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

I also stirred the bacon and tomatoes right into the egg salad, rather than just adding them as sandwich toppers. That way, you can enjoy this as a gluten-free option without bread, just nestled into a lettuce cup or on a bed of spinach.

Plus, it’s way easier for picnics and potlucks, since people can just scoop up perfect egg salad filled with yummy BLT flavors, without the fuss of having to wrangle tomato slices and strips of bacon. It’s even dip-able with crackers, tortilla chips, or flat pretzels (kinda like our ever-popular Egg-amole)!

Picnic perfect!

As in … don’t wait until next Easter to make this fantastic egg salad! Sure, sure – it’ll be your no-fail, go-to egg salad tradition every Easter (waaaaaaaay more predictable than the weather, ya know!). But it’ll also be your new fave picnic salad and summer sandwich filling.

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

BLT Egg Salad Recipe {}

In fact, no matter when you make it, this egg salad is one tradition you’ll always get right!

THK By Shelley

Looking for More Yummy Egg Salad Recipes to Use All Those Leftover Easter Eggs? Check Out …

Want a FREE Ebook Full of Great Recipes? We Thought So!

Just sign up in the little box at the top right corner of the page! We’ll send you a free ebook, filled with easy, healthy slow cooker recipes from top bloggers across the country! And to make sure you don’t miss a single deliciously healthy moment … you can like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter, and check out our awesome recipe boards on Pinterest.

BLT Egg Salad

Preparation 12 min. 2017-08-17T00:12:00+00:00 Cook Time 0 min. (assuming eggs and bacon are purchased or pre-cooked) 2017-08-17T00:00:00+00:00
Serves About 4½ cups     adjust servings


  • 12 hard-cooked eggs, chopped (6 yolks removed before chopping and reserved for another purpose – see notes)
  • 1 cup diced tomatoes (from about 1 large or two small tomatoes)
  • 3/4 cup nonfat plain Greek yogurt
  • 1/3 cup shredded, reduced-fat sharp cheddar cheese
  • 1/4 cup chopped or crumbled bacon (from about 3-4 slices, see note)
  • 2 tablespoons finely chopped green onion
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
  • 1/2 teaspoon white vinegar
  • 1/4 - 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt (see note)
  • 1/8 teaspoon black pepper
  • For serving: baby spinach or other greens as a sandwich topping or to make a salad; whole grain bread or toast for sandwiches; or whole grain crackers for dipping


  1. Gently combine all ingredients (except greens, and bread or crackers) in a medium bowl. Taste and adjust salt level as needed (see note).
  2. Serve immediately or cover and refrigerate until serving.
  3. Serve egg salad on whole grain bread or toast with baby spinach or other greens for sandwiches, or in large lettuce leaves or on a bed of greens for salads. Alternately, serve with whole grain crackers for dipping.


Recipe Notes

Eggs: For tips on making perfect hard-cooked eggs, be sure to check out our post on How to Hard-Cook Eggs for our researched, tested, tried-and-true method.

Yolks: We remove some of the yolks in this recipe simply because we prefer the taste and texture of this egg salad when it’s not quite so “yolk-y.” We’ve also tested this egg salad with all 12 yolks, though, and it's still very good. If you prefer your egg salad more "yolk-y" then you can certainly try that option if you don’t have another use for the yolks and don’t want to throw them away.

Bacon: If you choose to cook and then crumble your own bacon, we recommend selecting an organic or nitrate-free brand. In a pinch, however, to save time, we often use packaged real bacon bits (NOT Bac-Os), particularly since we don’t often use up entire packages of bacon quickly enough. Either option will work in this recipe.

Salt: There are a number of factors that can affect the amount of kosher salt you'll need for perfect flavor in this egg salad recipe, particularly the exact brands of bacon, cheese, and mustard you use. We recommend starting with ¼ teaspoon of kosher salt, tasting your egg salad, and then adjusting the salt up to ½ teaspoon or possibly ¾ teaspoon as needed.

Make ahead tips: This egg salad can be made ahead and refrigerated for a day or two before serving.

We'd love to see your photos of this recipe! Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Pinterest and Twitter and tag @TwoHealthyKitchens!


This recipe is loosely inspired by the Egg Salad BLTs recipe originally published by Cooking Light magazine in April 2007.

THK BLT Egg Salad Collage


BLT Egg Salad — 20 Comments

  1. Please folks do not waste your time making this. I did and it was so disgusting I had to throw a bunch of food away. Dont waste your time or money, there are better receipes out there

    • Hi Kimmy! Thanks so much for your feedback, although I’m so disappointed to hear this recipe didn’t work out for you! I absolutely love it and have made different variations of it so many times – it’s truly one of the traditions of Easter I most look forward to each year! I’m wondering if there might be something that I could help you troubleshoot? It may certainly be that this non-traditional spin on egg salad and its combination of BLT flavors just aren’t your thing, which is totally ok – but I’d be happy to help if I can! ~Shelley

      • Hi Kimmy – one idea. I’ve been really giving your problem a lot of thought, trying to figure out what could have gone so wrong for you. Other than a measurement that was way off (say, accidentally subbing tablespoons for teaspoons, which is pretty common), I did come up with one other idea. I’m wondering if you might possibly have accidentally grabbed VANILLA nonfat Greek yogurt instead of PLAIN? That definitely would have tasted pretty gross! And, as silly as it sounds, it’s easy to do – with many brands of yogurt, the containers look remarkably similar, and if you’re in a hurry, it’s easy to grab the wrong one, especially if the grocery store wasn’t careful about stocking them in precise, separated areas. I know I always have to be really careful which one I’m reaching for! Just a thought, but I hope that might help. Have a great week! ~Shelley

        • One other idea that just occurred to me: the salt. You’ll notice that we call for coarser-textured kosher salt in this egg salad recipe (as we do in many of our recipes). If you accidentally used regular, fine-grained table salt instead of the coarser kosher salt, that would cause a tremendous difference in saltiness, as the volume differences of coarse vs. fine salts can equate to approximately 3x the saltiness if you used fine salt instead of the kosher we call for. There’s a terrific discussion of that in this post on Serious Eats (, which explains that, “A cup of table salt will have twice the salting power of a cup of Diamond Crystal Kosher salt.” Just another idea for your troubleshooting! Thanks again! ~Shelley

  2. Pingback: Meal Plan Week #1 | Life is NOYOKE

  3. Pingback: Salmon BLT - Recipe Girl

  4. Pingback: 20 Healthy Low-Calorie Salads for Weight Loss

  5. Pingback: 21 Quick and Healthy Summer Lunches for Moms | Mom Fabulous

  6. Pingback: Summer Sandwich Recipes - Burlapkitchen

  7. Pingback: Chef's Favorite Easter Recipe - Event Group Catering

  8. Pingback: Food Bloggers' Best Healthy Cooking Tips and Swaps ... with Recipes! - Two Healthy Kitchens

  9. Pingback: 51 Tomato Recipes for Your Abundant Tomato Harvest |

  10. love this twist on egg salad! and fun reading about how you find this sort of recipe a long time ago in cooking light. i think your family traditions sounds just perfect.

Please Leave Us a Comment! We Love Hearing from You!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *